Most of what is understood about breed differences in aggression comes from reports based on bite statistics, behavior clinic caseloads, and experts opinions. Breed differences and genetic analysis abstract the absolute majority of dogs are kept as companion animals. Incidence rates of dog bites by breed at 2 usaf bases, january 1976december 1977. According to researchers, this suggests that aggression is a learnt response rather than a generalized character trait of a certain breed. Kottferova university of veterinary medicine and pharmacy in kosice, slovak republic abstract. While training can help manage most troublesome behaviors, people should look at breed traits when choosing a dog or puppy for their home. Nonetheless, there are published studies which address the question of breed differences in canine aggression. Information provided by respondents determines the identification of these breeds. Serpella, acenter for the interaction of animals and society, department of clinical studies. Longterm effects of early environments on the behavior and. Dog attacks cause 2030 human deathsyear in the usa. Although i can say that the motives for the samesex aggression were often quite different between males and females exhibiting the aggression. Breed differences in canine aggression article pdf available in applied animal behaviour science 11434. Issues of public safety and liability are a concern when canine aggression is involved.
Sometimes people use the term pit bull ban to describe breeddiscriminatory legislation, but bdl actually refers to legislation that prohibits any dog breed. It is unusual to have a dog to have just one type of. However, although the personality variation is welldocumented in many species, the ontogeny and development of personality is less studied. Dog shows threatening or aggressive responses to strangers approaching or invading the dogs or the owners personal space, territory, or home range.
To look at differences in behavior across dogs, the researchers tapped into the huge data pool from the canine behavioral assessment and research questionnaire cbarq. Although, testosterone is positively associated with aggression in many species archer, 1988, studies of androgens and aggression in dogs have been largely inconclusive. Differences in behavioral and psychological characteristics between dogs obtained as puppies from pet stores and those obtained from noncommercial. Aggression in canines is also a reaction to a person or animal violating a dogs personal space. Dog aggression expressed by dogs is considered to be normal behaviour and various types of aggression are influenced by a dogs environment and genetic predisposition. Nonetheless, findings from animal behavior science have repeatedly demonstrated the strong impact breed tendencies have on canine aggression and a dogs propensities to bite a person. Sep 09, 2017 new research shows that some types of fear and aggression in dogs are genetic, and can be divided into fear of the familiar and fear of the unfamiliar. Of all the potential behavior disorders, aggression is often the most disconcerting and dangerous. Canine aggression represents a significant public health hazard. Characteristics and risk factors of dog aggression in the. Strangerdirected aggression 10 items ownerdirected aggression 8 items dogdirected aggression.
Pit bull is the common name for a type of dog descended from bulldogs and terriers. Large and stable personality differences also called coping styles, temperament, behavioral syndrome are observed in many behavioral traits, such as in aggressiveness or fearfulness across species 12. Types of dog aggression aggression is one of the main reason dogs are euthanised or rehomed. Prevalence, comorbidity, and breed differences in canine anxiety in. The dog has been suggested as a possible model for personality development over. Information on breed specific aggressiveness derived from. Early life experiences and exercise associate with canine. Sex differences do emerge from data on various types of aggression.
Information on breed specific aggressiveness derived from such sources may be misleading due to biases attributable to a disproportionate risk of injury. Feb 22, 2018 yesterday, we wrote about popular fighting dogs, where canine aggression is an asset. Border collies displayed a very high prevalence of compulsive staring and fly. Endogenous oxytocin, vasopressin, and aggression in. Authors personal copy breed differences in canine aggression deborah l. At least 30% of all dogs in rescue centres are there because of the incidence of aggression in one form or another. Canine aggression in the pink dog grooming salon at taggerty. Strangerdirected aggression 10 items ownerdirected aggression 8 items dogdirected aggression 4 items familiar dog aggression 4 items strangerdirected fear 4 items dogdirected fear 4 items nonsocial fear 4 items attachmentattentionseeking 6 items separationrelated behavior 8 items touch sensitivity 4 items. Characteristics and risk factors of dog aggression in the slovak republic r.
A recent study breed differences in canine aggression took data from the cbarq. Breed differences in canine aggression semantic scholar. Numerous citations can be made from the animal behavior literature for example, for an overview see wright. The prevalence of dog breeds, age, sex, and reproductive status, needs to be established within the demographic population for which dog bites are to be investigated. However, while much is known about the physiology and neuroanatomy of such emotions, little is known about their genetics most importantly, why some individuals are more susceptible to pathology under stress. The gut microbiome correlates with conspecific aggression in. Canine behavior is often influenced by the breed s traits. Although i can say that the motives for the samesex aggression were often quite different between males. Longterm effects of early environments on the behavior. To assess breed differences in aggressiveness relative to fearfulness, we subtracted the population mean from the mean of each breed for stranger and dogdirected aggression and fear. Aggressiveness is often motivated by fear, and bite injuries resulting from humandirected aggression could be considered an important public health concern. The ratio of intact to spayedneutered dogs was significantly higher in the breed club sample. Breed differences in canine aggression by brenda bonnett the present study surveyed the owners of more than 30 breeds of dogs using the canine behavioral assessment and research questionnaire cbarq, a validated and reliable instrument for assessing dogs typical and recent responses to a variety of common stimuli and situations. However, exactly how breed perception and identification influences potential adopters decisions remains unclear.
Four primary approaches have been used to investigate breedrelated variation in aggressive behavior. Endogenous oxytocin, vasopressin, and aggression in domestic dogs. The canine behavioral assessment and research questionnaire identifies the most aggressive dogs by breed. Findings about breed differences in aggression in dogs. Aggressive behavior can be seen in dogs of any breed, size, age, and gender, and it can spring from many different motivations. Relative risk compared to mixed breed all p pdf available in applied animal behaviour science 11434. Behaviour problems and anxieties in dogs decrease their quality of life and may lead to relinquishment or euthanasia. Studies examining how behavior changes with age andor breed, rarely take into. Canine aggression is a widespread problem which receives a lot of attention from the media.
Breed differences in canine aggression researchgate. Id breed sex age years body masskg cephalic index fromdatabase neurocephalic index brain volumemm3 ostensiblebehavioral specializationpurpose 1 bassethound male 4. Breed specific canine aggression i love veterinary. The breed club and online samples differed from each other in three main respects. Pdf breed differences in canine aggression researchgate. Previous studies on the biology of canine aggression have focused predominantly on the role of androgens and the serotonergic system.
Four primary approaches have been used to investigate breedrelated variation in aggressive. Further genetic research is indicating that the differences in the genetic makeup of breed are so minute that drastic differences in temperament and aggressiveness are most likely not influenced by genetic disposition. Breed differences in canine behavior are heritable. Serpella, a center for the interaction of animals and society, department of clinical studies, school of veterinary medicine, university of pennsylvania, 3900 delancey street, philadelphia, pa 191046010, usa. Its a cross between a dog and, more often than not. We have here studied the prevalence, comorbidity, and breed specicity of seven canine anxietylike traits. Significantneuroanatomicalvariationamongdomestic dogbreeds. Canine aggression is the most common presenting complaint to behavioral specialists. Its a symptom of an underlying problem and it always needs to be taken seriously. May 06, 2016 the fact that we could successfully test the olfactory abilities of 85% of companion dogs from many different breeds and 92% of hand raised wolves in a simple procedure without any pretraining is evidence that the natural detection task has the potential to be a practical method for comparing the relative olfactory abilities of different.
Between 2005 and 2016, cbarq scores for nearly 30,000 dogs were collected by james serpell, an author of the paper. Today, i wanted to delve deeper into the science behind aggression in dogs, take a look at its causes and what. Canine aggression poses serious public health and animal welfare concerns. Aggression is a serious behavioral disorder in domestic dogs that endangers both dogs and humans. Sometimes people use the term pit bull ban to describe breeddiscriminatory legislation, but bdl actually refers. Previous research has indicated that certain breeds of dogs stay longer in shelters than others.
Aggression is not a characteristic of certain breeds. Breed differences in dogs affect aggression to a stranger. Background fearanxiety and anger aggression greatly influence health, quality of life and social interactions. Fearanxiety and angeraggression greatly influence health, quality of life and social interactions. The wolf hybrid is the most common wolftype dog breed. When focusing on individual breeds, these differences in prevalences resulted in breed specific patterns fig. One of my favorite studies was reported by a group of animal behaviorists at the university of pennsylvania duffy, d.
Firstly, breed had a significant effect on all of the six components, where labradors showed higher curiosity, play interest and threat display and goldens higher chase proneness, higher social. This could account for owners intolerance for larger dogs showing aggression, but again, why are the larger dogs getting banned when studies show aggressive behavior in small dogs as well. Aggression is the most serious behavior problem in dogs and is unfortunately quite common. To assess how breeds common to both the online and breed club datasets compared to one another, spearman rank order correlation coefficients were used to compare. Breeddiscriminatory legislation bdl is any law or policy that prohibits or places restrictions on individual dogs because of their supposed breed. Nonetheless, studies have shown some broad breed differences for canine aggressiveness borchelt, 1983, podberscek and serpell, 1997. The real fact is that there is a lack of data and scientific research that will serve as an opinion molding tool for the general public. Breed differences in canine aggression national taiwan. Does breed specific legislation reduce dog aggression on. Many find mixed breeds tend to have a better overall behavior than purebred breeds, but owning a mixed breed. Breed differences in canine aggression sciencedirect. Crosssectional age differences in canine personality. From the dogs perspective, aggression is a communication strategy.
Dogs commonly display possessive aggression when defending resources or themselves. Dogs kept as family pets are frequently exposed to noisy and crowded environments, and often have to interact with unfamiliar dogs and humans. Similar recent selection criteria associated with different. These include things such as stranger directed aggression sda, dogdirected aggression dda and owner. Dog expert opinion on the most aggressive dog breeds. Owners, not breeds, predict whether dogs will be aggressive. Current dog breed identification practices in animal shelters are often based upon information supplied by the relinquishing owner, or staff determination based on the dogs phenotype. The findings also emphasized that training methods play an important role in determining how a dog will interact with humans. Prevalence, comorbidity, and breed differences in canine. Nov 03, 2015 canine personality has a large impact on both the canines and the owners welfare. Its a cross between a dog and, more often than not, the grey wolf although other wolves can. Differences between and within breeds are shown in fig. The underlying causes of canine aggression are poorly resolved and require illumination to ensure effective therapy.
In fact, many lectures on canine genetics begin with a statement about genetic differences in behavior, but few of the genes are known. They are a huge burden to wellbeing, and personal and public economics. The science behind aggression in dogs top dog tips. Genetic mapping of canine fear and aggression bmc genomics. This is a complex topic and doesnt offer simple and universal answers which can be considered definitive and appropriate. Mar 04, 2014 owners, not breeds, predict whether dogs will be aggressive researchers suggest training your dog well and early on to avoid any problems with aggressionregardless of what breed youve got. Canine behavior is often influenced by the breeds traits.
680 64 829 306 1087 201 1358 1039 1483 901 61 322 1550 347 1529 511 1370 1178 992 1065 995 1041 1367 301 427 1335 384 1031 379 752 447 90 1172 882 605 643 136 22 1473